Oyster Bay Homes for Sale

Oyster Bay Homes for Sale

Welcome to Oyster Bay, a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque Fernandina Beach, Florida. This charming subdivision lies within Nassau County and is the perfect blend of coastal elegance and serene living. With its lush landscapes and tranquil waterways, Oyster Bay offers a unique lifestyle that appeals to both families and retirees alike.

The homes for sale in Oyster Bay are a testament to the beauty and craftsmanship that define this community. Ranging from modern coastal designs to classic Southern architecture, each residence is thoughtfully constructed to provide comfort and style. Many homes boast spacious layouts, gourmet kitchens, and outdoor living spaces that invite you to soak in the stunning Florida sunshine. With prices that cater to a variety of budgets, you’re sure to find the perfect home that fits your needs.

Living in Oyster Bay means enjoying the best of both worlds: a peaceful retreat while being just minutes away from the vibrant attractions of Fernandina Beach. Spend your weekends exploring the pristine beaches, indulging in local seafood cuisine, or taking a stroll through the charming historic district. For outdoor enthusiasts, the area offers abundant opportunities for boating, fishing, and golfing, ensuring that you’ll never run out of adventures.

Whether you’re looking to settle down in a family-friendly environment or seeking a vacation home that captures the essence of coastal living, Oyster Bay is the perfect destination. Discover your dream home today in this enchanting community, where tranquility meets the allure of beachside living!

Newest Oyster Bay Homes for Sale

$1,175,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 116993 MLS
Your ultimate coastal retreat awaits in the premier gated community of Oyster Bay Harbour in Fernandina Beach along the St Mary’s river. Enter the home through a mahogany door to a one-of-a-kind custom home where you are welcomed to a light-filled home, characterized by soaring 12-foot ceilings with crown molding, hardwood hickory floors, and an expansive great room with gas fireplace. The gourmet kitchen was built with ample cabinetry and oversized quartz island. This home was designed for everyday living as well as effortless entertainment, inclusive of built in cabinetry and wet bar. The home offers three en-suite bedrooms with ample closet space for ultimate comfort. Two suites reside on the main level, including a luxurious primary retreat complete with bay window seating and an oversized walk-in shower. Upstairs, the flexible third suite easily adapts as a guest sanctuary, office, media room, or secondary living space. A sliding glass wall opens to a spacious screened-in tiled lanai and paved patio overlooking a serene lagoon. Fenced in yard provides ample space for a future pool, outdoor kitchen, or private garden oasis. Within Oyster Bay Harbour residents enjoy pickleball, clay tennis courts, RV and boat storage, and community pool. With an acceptable offer, the Seller will include a paid equity membership to Oyster Bay Yacht Club, unlocking deep-water access, private in-community boat docks, world-class dining, member events, and premier waterfront privileges.

96133 Oyster Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach
$1,065,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 116859 MLS
Wake up to spectacular sunrises over the marsh and Amelia River from this beautifully designed coastal home in gated Oyster Bay Harbour. Just down the street from the Oyster Bay Yacht Club, this LIKE-NEW HOME offers 2,812 sq-ft of thoughtfully planned living space with 3 bedrooms + a dedicated office/flex room, 2.5 baths and captivating east-facing water views. An open-concept design fills the home with natural light while showcasing the scenic surroundings. The spacious great room, dining area and chef-inspired kitchen flow seamlessly together, creating an inviting setting for both relaxed everyday living and entertaining. Outdoor living spaces provide the perfect place to enjoy coastal breezes, watch wildlife along the marsh and begin each day with a stunning sunrise over the river. Elevated construction enhances the views and provides exceptional functionality. The ground level features a generous three-car tandem garage with abundant space for vehicles, a golf cart, water toys and additional storage. A PRIVATE ELEVATOR offers convenient access to the home’s main living levels. Oyster Bay Harbour residents enjoy a community pool, new pickleball courts, clay tennis courts and potential secure boat or RV storage. Optional membership at the nearby Oyster Bay Yacht Club provides access to dining, a deep-water marina, boat slips, kayak launch, fishing bridge, fitness room and pool. Located just minutes from Amelia Island’s beaches and historic downtown Fernandina Beach—and less than 30 minutes from Jacksonville International Airport—this exceptional home combines panoramic coastal beauty, thoughtful design and the coveted Oyster Bay lifestyle.

96558 Compass Point Drive, Fernandina Beach
$825,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 115784 MLS
Located in the gated Oyster Bay community, this beautifully updated 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home offers a bright, functional layout with modern finishes throughout. The main living areas feature new luxury vinyl plank flooring, while the updated kitchen includes granite countertops, newer stainless steel appliances, and a gas stove. Perfect for everyday living and entertaining. A dedicated office adds flexibility for work or study. The primary suite is conveniently located on the first floor and features a beautifully renovated shower. Upstairs offers additional bedrooms and updated bath space for family or guests. Enjoy peace of mind with major updates already completed, including a roof replaced in 2019, 2 new HVAC condenser units. Additional improvements include new front doors and recently renovated primary and upstairs showers, totaling approximately $31,000 in upgrades. Relax or entertain on the screened-in lanai overlooking a private setting. Ideally located just minutes from Amelia Island, this home offers the perfect blend of comfort and convenience.

96058 Bay View Drive, Fernandina Beach
Start Your Search
© 2026 Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. This data up-to-date as of . For the most current information, contact Florida Homes Realty and Mortgage.